Our Family Genealogy Pages

Discovering our Ancestors

First Name Last Name
Home Search Login  
Print Bookmark
William S Warren

William S Warren

Male 1830 - 1914  (84 years)

Generations:      Standard    |    Compact    |    Vertical    |    Text    |    Register    |    Tables    |    PDF

More detail
Generation: 1

  1. 1.  William S WarrenWilliam S Warren was born in 1830 in Green, Kentucky, USA; died on 23 Feb 1914 in Green, Kentucky, USA.

    William married Mary Elizabeth Warren on 28 Apr 1853 in ,Green,Kentucky,USA. Mary (daughter of Nathan Warren and Lydia Skaggs) was born in 1836 in Green County, KY USA; died in 1900 in Green, Kentucky, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 2. Lewis Chatham Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 28 Apr 1855 in Green, Kentucky, United States; died on 2 Feb 1933 in Larue, Kentucky, United States; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    2. 3. Cleopatra Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 27 Aug 1861 in , Green, Kentucky, USA.
    3. 4. Lydia E Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1866 in , , Kentucky, USA.
    4. 5. Phebe Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1867 in , , Kentucky, USA.
    5. 6. Josey Green Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1875 in , Green, Kentucky, USA.


Generation: 2

  1. 2.  Lewis Chatham WarrenLewis Chatham Warren Descendancy chart to this point (1.William1) was born on 28 Apr 1855 in Green, Kentucky, United States; died on 2 Feb 1933 in Larue, Kentucky, United States; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

    Lewis married Celia Ann Perkins on 23 Apr 1876 in Larue. Celia was born on 8 Dec 1858 in Kentucky, USA; died on 23 Dec 1935 in Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 7. Mary Elizabeth "Lizzie" Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1876 in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America; died in 1902 in Larue, Kentucky, United States; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    2. 8. Emily F. Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1879 in Kentucky, United States.
    3. 9. William Patrick Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 20 Oct 1882 in Kentucky, USA; died on 10 May 1923 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    4. 10. Robert James Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in Nov 1883 in Kentucky; died on 9 September 1958 in Kentucky, United States.
    5. 11. Rildy Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 26 Mar 1887 in Kentucky; died on 31 Jan 1914 in Larue, Kentucky, USA.
    6. 12. Arrelda Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 26 March 1887 in Kentucky; died on 31 Jan 1914 in Larue, Kentucky.
    7. 13. Jesse Rodman Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 28 May 1887 in Kentucky, United States; died on 5 Jul 1959 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.
    8. 14. Emmett Irvin Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 20 Jan 1890 in Kentucky; died on 16 Jul 1963 in Tiskilwa, Bureau, Illinois, United States.
    9. 15. Josie Jane Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 22 Sep 1891 in Kentucky, USA; died on 15 Aug 1980 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    10. 16. Leatha M Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 1 Oct 1895 in Kentucky; died in 1959 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.
    11. 17. Sabrina Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in May 1898 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.
    12. 18. Savannah Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 17 May 1899 in Laure Co., KY.; died in 03-11-1974 in Kentucky, USA.
    13. 19. Louise Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1900 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.

  2. 3.  Cleopatra WarrenCleopatra Warren Descendancy chart to this point (1.William1) was born on 27 Aug 1861 in , Green, Kentucky, USA.

  3. 4.  Lydia E WarrenLydia E Warren Descendancy chart to this point (1.William1) was born in 1866 in , , Kentucky, USA.

  4. 5.  Phebe WarrenPhebe Warren Descendancy chart to this point (1.William1) was born in 1867 in , , Kentucky, USA.

  5. 6.  Josey Green WarrenJosey Green Warren Descendancy chart to this point (1.William1) was born in 1875 in , Green, Kentucky, USA.


Generation: 3

  1. 7.  Mary Elizabeth "Lizzie" WarrenMary Elizabeth "Lizzie" Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1876 in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America; died in 1902 in Larue, Kentucky, United States; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

    Mary married Richard Sissum Skaggs in 1894 in KY. Richard (son of William J Skaggs and Elizabeth Pierce) was born on 15 Aug 1874 in , Larue, Kentucky USA; died on 14 Dec 1932 in , Larue, Kentucky USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 20. William L Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 27 Oct 1896 in Larue,Kentucky; died on 19 Mar 1981 in Hodgenville, Larue, Kentucky; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    2. 21. James Holland Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 2 Jun 1900 in Larue County KY; died on 12 Oct 1947 in Larue, Kentucky; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

  2. 8.  Emily F. WarrenEmily F. Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1879 in Kentucky, United States.

  3. 9.  William Patrick WarrenWilliam Patrick Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 20 Oct 1882 in Kentucky, USA; died on 10 May 1923 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

    William married Mary Warren on 06 Mar 1900 in Larue, Kentucky, USA. Mary (daughter of Richard Archie Warren and Malinda Ann DeSpain) was born on 21 Mar 1884 in Kentucky; died on 10 May 1923; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 22. Gertrude Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in Bet. 1895–1910 in KY; died in 1963.
    2. 23. Richard Patrick Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1898 in Kentucky, USA.
    3. 24. Roy Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1900 in Kentucky.
    4. 25. Richard Lewis "Paddy" Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 12 Dec 1903 in KY; died on 08 Jul 1969.
    5. 26. Edith Catherine Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 4 Mar 1904 in Kentucky, USA; died on 15 Oct 1974 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    6. 27. Sylvester Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 27 Jan 1905 in Green, Kentucky, USA; died on 19 Apr 1959 in Green, Kentucky, USA.
    7. 28. Dorothy Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1906.
    8. 29. Rett Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1908.
    9. 30. Alvin W Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 08 Oct 1908 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; died on 03 Oct 1973 in Larue, Kentucky, USA.

  4. 10.  Robert James WarrenRobert James Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in Nov 1883 in Kentucky; died on 9 September 1958 in Kentucky, United States.

  5. 11.  Rildy WarrenRildy Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 26 Mar 1887 in Kentucky; died on 31 Jan 1914 in Larue, Kentucky, USA.

  6. 12.  Arrelda WarrenArrelda Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 26 March 1887 in Kentucky; died on 31 Jan 1914 in Larue, Kentucky.

    Arrelda married Leslie Wesley Warren on 14 Apr 1907. Leslie (son of Wesley Warren and Louisa Eliza Elkins) was born in 1882 in Green, Kentucky, United States; died on 24 May 1929 in Hodgenville, Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 31. Everette Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 10 Nov 1906 in Larue County KY; died on 29 Nov 1991 in Campbelsvlle, Larue, Kentucky, United States.
    2. 32. Shirley Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born in 1908 in Kentucky; died in 1931 in Larue, Kentucky, United States,.
    3. 33. Herman E. Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born about 1909 in Kentucky.
    4. 34. Creed Arties Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 8 Dec 1911 in Kentucky; died on 7 July 2005 in La Grange, Oldham, Kentucky, USA.

  7. 13.  Jesse Rodman WarrenJesse Rodman Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 28 May 1887 in Kentucky, United States; died on 5 Jul 1959 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.

  8. 14.  Emmett Irvin WarrenEmmett Irvin Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 20 Jan 1890 in Kentucky; died on 16 Jul 1963 in Tiskilwa, Bureau, Illinois, United States.

  9. 15.  Josie Jane WarrenJosie Jane Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 22 Sep 1891 in Kentucky, USA; died on 15 Aug 1980 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

    Josie married John Thomas Warren on 17 April 1908 in Larue, Kentucky, USA. John (son of Wesley Warren and Louisa Eliza Elkins) was born on 3 Jul 1887 in Green, Kentucky, USA; died on 16 Nov 1969 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 35. Elsie Alice Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 26 April 1909 in Kentucky, USA; died on 27 December 1993 in Hardin County, Kentucky, USA.
    2. 36. Pansy Pariline Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 22 March 1912 in Green County, Kentucky, USA; died on 28 August 1981 in Louisville, Jefferson County, Kentucky, USA.
    3. 37. Herbert Wesley Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 2 June 1916 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 24 August 1996 in Taylor County, Kentucky, USA.
    4. 38. Ernest Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 30 April 1920 in Kentucky, USA; died on 5 May 1920 in Kentucky, USA.
    5. 39. Lola Margaret Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 30 July 1923 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 17 August 2000 in Hardin County, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    6. 40. Blonde Edward Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 23 Dec 1925 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 24 Oct 1955 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    7. 41. Alco Lee Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 23 May 1928 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; died on 8 Nov 2017 in Springfield, Washington, Kentucky, USA.
    8. 42. Opal Christine Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 5 October 1930 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 27 April 2008 in Elizabethtown, Hardin County, Kentucky, USA.
    9. 43. Herman Lilbern Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 13 July 1934 in Kentucky, USA; died on 1 February 1953 in Barren County, Kentucky, USA.
    10. 44. Unknown Warren  Descendancy chart to this point

  10. 16.  Leatha M WarrenLeatha M Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 1 Oct 1895 in Kentucky; died in 1959 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.

  11. 17.  Sabrina WarrenSabrina Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in May 1898 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.

  12. 18.  Savannah WarrenSavannah Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 17 May 1899 in Laure Co., KY.; died in 03-11-1974 in Kentucky, USA.

  13. 19.  Louise WarrenLouise Warren Descendancy chart to this point (2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1900 in Larue, Kentucky, United States.


Generation: 4

  1. 20.  William L SkaggsWilliam L Skaggs Descendancy chart to this point (7.Mary3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 27 Oct 1896 in Larue,Kentucky; died on 19 Mar 1981 in Hodgenville, Larue, Kentucky; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

  2. 21.  James Holland SkaggsJames Holland Skaggs Descendancy chart to this point (7.Mary3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 2 Jun 1900 in Larue County KY; died on 12 Oct 1947 in Larue, Kentucky; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

  3. 22.  Gertrude WarrenGertrude Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in Bet. 1895–1910 in KY; died in 1963.

  4. 23.  Richard Patrick WarrenRichard Patrick Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1898 in Kentucky, USA.

  5. 24.  Roy WarrenRoy Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1900 in Kentucky.

  6. 25.  Richard Lewis "Paddy" WarrenRichard Lewis "Paddy" Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 12 Dec 1903 in KY; died on 08 Jul 1969.

  7. 26.  Edith Catherine WarrenEdith Catherine Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 4 Mar 1904 in Kentucky, USA; died on 15 Oct 1974 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

    Edith married Raymond Alex DeSpain in Apr 1939. Raymond (son of Richard Marshall DeSpain and Ida Frances Skaggs) was born on 19 Mar 1918 in Kentucky; died on 24 Feb 2001 in Elizabethtown, Hardin Co., Kentucky; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 45. Margie M. Towles  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 7 September 1940 in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

  8. 27.  Sylvester WarrenSylvester Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 27 Jan 1905 in Green, Kentucky, USA; died on 19 Apr 1959 in Green, Kentucky, USA.

  9. 28.  Dorothy WarrenDorothy Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1906.

  10. 29.  Rett WarrenRett Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1908.

  11. 30.  Alvin W WarrenAlvin W Warren Descendancy chart to this point (9.William3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 08 Oct 1908 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; died on 03 Oct 1973 in Larue, Kentucky, USA.

  12. 31.  Everette WarrenEverette Warren Descendancy chart to this point (12.Arrelda3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 10 Nov 1906 in Larue County KY; died on 29 Nov 1991 in Campbelsvlle, Larue, Kentucky, United States.

  13. 32.  Shirley WarrenShirley Warren Descendancy chart to this point (12.Arrelda3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born in 1908 in Kentucky; died in 1931 in Larue, Kentucky, United States,.

  14. 33.  Herman E. WarrenHerman E. Warren Descendancy chart to this point (12.Arrelda3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born about 1909 in Kentucky.

  15. 34.  Creed Arties WarrenCreed Arties Warren Descendancy chart to this point (12.Arrelda3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 8 Dec 1911 in Kentucky; died on 7 July 2005 in La Grange, Oldham, Kentucky, USA.

    Creed married Nellie Skaggs on 26 June 1935 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA. Nellie (daughter of Edward McClain Skaggs and Zilpha Warren) was born on 25 Aug 1915 in Green, Kentucky, USA; died on 10 Apr 1959 in Jefferson, Kentucky, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 46. Hellen Juanita Warren, (67 cMs)  Descendancy chart to this point
    2. 47. Margie May Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 21 August 1939 in Green County, Kentucky, USA; died on 8 November 1999 in Louisville, Jefferson County, Kentucky, USA.
    3. 48. Artie Warren  Descendancy chart to this point
    4. 49. Barlene Gaw  Descendancy chart to this point
    5. 50. Ja Verne Warren  Descendancy chart to this point
    6. 51. Virgil Warren  Descendancy chart to this point

  16. 35.  Elsie Alice WarrenElsie Alice Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 26 April 1909 in Kentucky, USA; died on 27 December 1993 in Hardin County, Kentucky, USA.

  17. 36.  Pansy Pariline WarrenPansy Pariline Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 22 March 1912 in Green County, Kentucky, USA; died on 28 August 1981 in Louisville, Jefferson County, Kentucky, USA.

  18. 37.  Herbert Wesley WarrenHerbert Wesley Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 2 June 1916 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 24 August 1996 in Taylor County, Kentucky, USA.

    Family/Spouse: Velma Lois Henry. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 52. Robert Thomas Warren  Descendancy chart to this point
    2. 53. Deborah Warren  Descendancy chart to this point

    Family/Spouse: Atwell. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 54. Regina Warren  Descendancy chart to this point
    2. 55. Judy Warren  Descendancy chart to this point

    Family/Spouse: Unknown. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 56. Eric Warren  Descendancy chart to this point

  19. 38.  Ernest WarrenErnest Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 30 April 1920 in Kentucky, USA; died on 5 May 1920 in Kentucky, USA.

  20. 39.  Lola Margaret WarrenLola Margaret Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 30 July 1923 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 17 August 2000 in Hardin County, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

    Lola married Fordyce Young Skaggs on 8 Dec 1940 in Hodgenville, Kentucky. Fordyce was born on 12 Sep 1918 in Green Co., Kentucky; died on 09 Sep 2003 in Mount Sherman, Larue, Kentucky; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 57. Kenneth Young Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 24 May 1941 in Green County, Kentucky, United States of America; died on 22 April 2017 in Mount Sherman, Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    2. 58. Fordyce Skaggs, Jr  Descendancy chart to this point
    3. 59. Billy Raymond Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 23 May 1946 in Green, Kentucky; died on 08 May 2001 in Mount Sherman, LaRue Co., Kentucky; was buried in Hodgenville, Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    4. 60. Larry Eugene Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 08 Dec 1950 in La Rue, Kentucky; died on 10 Jan 2009 in Cincinnati, Hamilton, Ohio; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.
    5. 61. Sandra S Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point
    6. 62. Mark Thomas Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point
    7. 63. Barbara Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point
    8. 64. Roger Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point

  21. 40.  Blonde Edward WarrenBlonde Edward Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 23 Dec 1925 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 24 Oct 1955 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; was buried in Larue County, Kentucky, United States of America.

  22. 41.  Alco Lee WarrenAlco Lee Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 23 May 1928 in Larue, Kentucky, USA; died on 8 Nov 2017 in Springfield, Washington, Kentucky, USA.

    Alco married Doris Maxine Burton in 05-31-1947 in Jeffersonville, Clark County, Indiana. Doris was born on 14 Jan 1938 in Louisville, Jefferson, Kentucky, USA; died on 3 Sep 2008 in Elizabeth, Harrison County, Indiana, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 65. Alco Lee Warren, (50.7 cMs)  Descendancy chart to this point
    2. 66. David Warren  Descendancy chart to this point
    3. 67. Danny Lee Warren  Descendancy chart to this point
    4. 68. Warren (Archibald)  Descendancy chart to this point
    5. 69. Rick Warren  Descendancy chart to this point

    Family/Spouse: Thelma Jean Gregory. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 70. Everett Wayne Warren  Descendancy chart to this point was born on 5 Oct 1947 in Louisville, Jefferson, Kentucky, USA; died on 7 Nov 2015 in Elizabeth, Harrison, Indiana, USA.
    2. 71. Douglas Raymond Warren  Descendancy chart to this point

  23. 42.  Opal Christine WarrenOpal Christine Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 5 October 1930 in Larue County, Kentucky, USA; died on 27 April 2008 in Elizabethtown, Hardin County, Kentucky, USA.

    Family/Spouse: James T Skaggs. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 72. Frances Diane Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point
    2. 73. Bryant Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point
    3. 74. Jimmy Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point
    4. 75. Ricky Skaggs  Descendancy chart to this point

  24. 43.  Herman Lilbern WarrenHerman Lilbern Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1) was born on 13 July 1934 in Kentucky, USA; died on 1 February 1953 in Barren County, Kentucky, USA.

  25. 44.  Unknown WarrenUnknown Warren Descendancy chart to this point (15.Josie3, 2.Lewis2, 1.William1)

    Family/Spouse: Unknown. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

    Children:
    1. 76. AW Warren, (44 cMs)  Descendancy chart to this point